PS5003ACC: Collins Industries Case Study ( 2024-25) Managerial and Strategic Recommendations
| University | Faculty of Business Environment and Society (BES) |
| Subject | Management Accounting |
Collins Industries Case Study
Overview
Collins Industries is a decentralized organization with five divisions. Among these, the Electrical Division manufactures various electrical items, including the A21 electrical fitting. The division, currently operating at capacity, sells the A21 fitting for $7.50 each, which has a variable manufacturing cost of $4.25.
Scenario Analysis
The Brake Division, operating at 50% capacity, has requested the Electrical Division to supply the A21 fitting at $5 each. The Brake Division plans to use the fitting in a brake unit for a commercial airline manufacturer. The unit cost for producing the brake unit includes:
Hire a Professional Essay & Assignment Writer for completing your Academic Assessments
- Purchased parts (from outside vendors): $22.50
- Electrical fitting A21: $5.00
- Other variable costs: $14.00
- Fixed overhead and administration: $8.00
- Total cost per brake unit: $49.50
Key Issues
- The Brake Division risks losing the contract if the brake unit price exceeds $50.
- If the Electrical Division maintains the $7.50 price, the Brake Division may suffer losses.
- Collins Industries evaluates performance using ROI and profit measures.
Recommendations
a) Decision for Supplying A21 Fittings
As the manager of the Electrical Division, I recommend against supplying the fittings at $5. This price would not cover the variable costs of $4.25 and would reduce the division’s ROI.
Buy Custom Answer of This Assessment & Raise Your Grades
b) Economic Advantage to the Company
Supplying the fittings at $5 could benefit the company as a whole by securing the Brake Division’s contract. Full computations can illustrate the overall impact.
c) Transfer Price Agreement
Managers can negotiate a transfer price between $4.25 (variable cost) and $7.50 (market price). The optimal range maximizes both divisional and organizational performance.
d) Organizational Behavior Issues
Conflicts between divisional goals and organizational objectives may arise. Clear communication and revised performance metrics are necessary to align interests.
Information Systems Upgrade
The board is considering an integrated system using a single database. This system would enhance real-time data input and support management decisions with financial and non-financial metrics.
External Non-Financial Information
- Customer Satisfaction Surveys: To gauge client perspectives.
- Supplier Performance Metrics: To evaluate timeliness and quality.
- Market Trends Analysis: To anticipate industry shifts.
Collecting this data supports strategic planning and competitive advantage.
Stuck with a lot of homework assignments and feeling stressed ? Take professional academic assistance & Get 100% Plagiarism free papers
- ESG531 Circular Economy for a Sustainable Future Group-Based Assignment: Circular Transformation Roadmap for SMEs towards 2030
- Business Marketing Assignment: Showcasing Fresco Pizza Hub’s Competitive Advantage over MegaSlice Pizza
- ECE210 Advocacy and Collaborations with Families Assignment: Supporting Grieving Children Through Culturally Responsive and Family-Centred Practices
- ACC707 Accounting and Finance Assignment: Evaluating Investment Decisions, Budgeting Practices, and Financial Performance through Ratio Analysis
- NCO201 Learn to Learn, Learn for Life TMA01: Developing Self-Awareness and Strategies for Lifelong Learning
- PSS219 Public Safety and Security in Singapore Group-Based Assignment: Analyzing Ministry Strategies and Challenges from the 2025 Committee of Supply Debate
- MTH240 Engineering Mathematics I TMA: Applications of Linear Algebra in Engineering Problems and System Analysis
- Engaging Youth with IBM Skills Build Assignment: Developing Creative Approaches to Boost Skills and Career Prospects
- BUS368 Innovation Management and Digital Transformation Assignment: Managing Innovation and Uncertainty in Foldable, Trifold, and Stretchable Display Technologies
- BUS366 Assignment: Enhancing Process Efficiency and Recruitment Effectiveness through Lean Six Sigma Methodologies
UP TO 15 % DISCOUNT